PGP subject signing trigger behaves differently in CipherMail 6.5 than in 5.4

Hello,

I am running CipherMail Community Gateway 6.5.0.0g55060922. I want outgoing emails to be signed with PGP only when the subject contains (s). Emails without (s) should remain unsigned.

This worked as expected with CipherMail 5.4. In that version, I had “Only sign when encrypt” enabled and “Skip signing only” disabled. With those settings, the subject trigger signed messages containing (s), while messages without the trigger remained unsigned.

In version 6.5, I cannot get the same behavior. The PGP subject signing trigger is enabled with the regular expression \(s\). The trigger is detected in the backend log, and the matched text is removed from the subject as configured. PGP is enabled, PGP/MIME is selected for outgoing messages, and S/MIME is disabled for the sender. A PGP signing key is present and assigned to the sender address. There are no individual user settings for the recipient.

The “Skip Sign Only” setting produces this behavior in version 6.5:

  • Enabled: No message is signed, including messages whose subject contains (s).

  • Disabled: All outgoing messages are signed, including messages without (s).

Despite the trigger being detected, the message is delivered without a PGP signature.

Has the behavior or meaning of “Only sign when encrypt” or “Skip signing only” changed between versions 5.4 and 6.5? Is there a setting in version 6.5 that provides the same behavior as my version 5.4 configuration?

Kind regards,

André

Are you absolutely certain this worked with V5.4? Because I think this only worked with S/MIME.

Yes, I am absolutely certain. We have been using this configuration for years. We currently have 10 users (senders) with PGP keys. A PGP key is only created for a sender when a signature is triggered via the subject line. I tested this again today. At the moment, CipherMail 5 is in production, while CipherMail 6 is being used in a test environment.

If I re-enable the “skip-sign-only” option, how else can I trigger the creation of a signature?

Than it’s probably a bug. We’ll look into it.

1 Like

Thank you for your effort. I am sending you the log entries for four test emails.

If I knew how the sender could automatically create and send a PGP signature, everything would be fine. At the moment, I don’t see how that’s supposed to work when the trigger is detected but then overwritten.

Please let me know if you need any further information.

  1. Message “Test” – no trigger, “Skip Sign Only” disabled
    Result: Message was signed.

2.11.2026, 18:34:19 ciphermail-backend
INFO Processing is finished; MailID: 277d365a-0b69-4e88-a854-3ff40b7ebb38; Recipients: [receiver@external-domain.net]; Originator: sender@internal-domain.net; Sender: sender@internal-domain.net; Remote address: 192.168.7.28; Subject: Test; Message-ID: 4a4644804d384dffa2958b4c8946baef@internal-domain.net; (com.ciphermail.core.app.james.mailets.Log) [spooler-740]
2.11.2026, 18:34:19 ciphermail-backend
INFO DKIM signing is disabled for the sender; MailID: 277d365a-0b69-4e88-a854-3ff40b7ebb38; Recipients: [receiver@external-domain.net] (com.ciphermail.core.app.james.mailets.Default) [spooler-740]
2.11.2026, 18:34:19 ciphermail-backend
INFO Message was PGP/MIME signed. Hash algorithm: SHA256; MailID: 277d365a-0b69-4e88-a854-3ff40b7ebb38; Recipients: [receiver@external-domain.net] (com.ciphermail.core.app.james.mailets.PGPMIMESign) [spooler-740]
2.11.2026, 18:34:19 ciphermail-backend
INFO Trying to PGP/MIME sign the message; MailID: 277d365a-0b69-4e88-a854-3ff40b7ebb38; Recipients: [receiver@external-domain.net] (com.ciphermail.core.app.james.mailets.Default) [spooler-740]
2.11.2026, 18:34:19 ciphermail-backend
INFO Check for sender PGP key and request one if required; MailID: 277d365a-0b69-4e88-a854-3ff40b7ebb38; Recipients: [receiver@external-domain.net] (com.ciphermail.core.app.james.mailets.Default) [spooler-740]
2.11.2026, 18:34:18 ciphermail-backend
INFO S/MIME Skip Sign Only is enabled for the sender; MailID: 277d365a-0b69-4e88-a854-3ff40b7ebb38; Recipients: [receiver@external-domain.net] (com.ciphermail.core.app.james.mailets.Default) [spooler-740]
2.11.2026, 18:34:18 ciphermail-backend
INFO Encrypt Mode is No Encryption for the sender; MailID: 277d365a-0b69-4e88-a854-3ff40b7ebb38; Recipients: [receiver@external-domain.net] (com.ciphermail.core.app.james.mailets.Default) [spooler-740]
2.11.2026, 18:34:18 ciphermail-backend
INFO DLP is disabled for the sender; MailID: 277d365a-0b69-4e88-a854-3ff40b7ebb38; Recipients: [receiver@external-domain.net] (com.ciphermail.core.app.james.mailets.Default) [spooler-740]
2.11.2026, 18:34:18 ciphermail-backend
INFO To external recipient(s); MailID: 277d365a-0b69-4e88-a854-3ff40b7ebb38; Recipients: [receiver@external-domain.net] (com.ciphermail.core.app.james.mailets.Default) [spooler-740]
2.11.2026, 18:34:18 ciphermail-backend
INFO Subject filter is disabled for the sender; MailID: 277d365a-0b69-4e88-a854-3ff40b7ebb38; Recipients: [receiver@external-domain.net] (com.ciphermail.core.app.james.mailets.Default) [spooler-740]
2.11.2026, 18:34:18 ciphermail-backend
INFO Received ; MailID: 277d365a-0b69-4e88-a854-3ff40b7ebb38; Recipients: [receiver@external-domain.net]; Originator: sender@internal-domain.net; Sender: sender@internal-domain.net; Remote address: 192.168.7.28; Subject: Test; Message-ID: 4a4644804d384dffa2958b4c8946baef@internal-domain.net; (com.ciphermail.core.app.james.mailets.Log) [spooler-740]

  1. Message “(s) Test with signature trigger” – “Skip Sign Only” disabled
    Result: Message was signed.

2.11.2026, 18:34:58 ciphermail-backend
INFO Processing is finished; MailID: fffa12a9-94f6-43ff-88eb-de9071dfcaf2; Recipients: [receiver@external-domain.net]; Originator: sender@internal-domain.net; Sender: sender@internal-domain.net; Remote address: 192.168.7.28; Subject: Test mit Signatur Trigger; Message-ID: 22cd7ba45be94449b7506e7498abbcae@internal-domain.net; (com.ciphermail.core.app.james.mailets.Log) [spooler-740]
2.11.2026, 18:34:58 ciphermail-backend
INFO DKIM signing is disabled for the sender; MailID: fffa12a9-94f6-43ff-88eb-de9071dfcaf2; Recipients: [receiver@external-domain.net] (com.ciphermail.core.app.james.mailets.Default) [spooler-740]
2.11.2026, 18:34:58 ciphermail-backend
INFO Message was PGP/MIME signed. Hash algorithm: SHA256; MailID: fffa12a9-94f6-43ff-88eb-de9071dfcaf2; Recipients: [receiver@external-domain.net] (com.ciphermail.core.app.james.mailets.PGPMIMESign) [spooler-740]
2.11.2026, 18:34:58 ciphermail-backend
INFO Trying to PGP/MIME sign the message; MailID: fffa12a9-94f6-43ff-88eb-de9071dfcaf2; Recipients: [receiver@external-domain.net] (com.ciphermail.core.app.james.mailets.Default) [spooler-740]
2.11.2026, 18:34:58 ciphermail-backend
INFO Check for sender PGP key and request one if required; MailID: fffa12a9-94f6-43ff-88eb-de9071dfcaf2; Recipients: [receiver@external-domain.net] (com.ciphermail.core.app.james.mailets.Default) [spooler-740]
2.11.2026, 18:34:58 ciphermail-backend
INFO S/MIME is disabled for the sender; MailID: fffa12a9-94f6-43ff-88eb-de9071dfcaf2; Recipients: [receiver@external-domain.net] (com.ciphermail.core.app.james.mailets.Default) [spooler-740]
2.11.2026, 18:34:58 ciphermail-backend
INFO The subject contains the Sign Trigger for the sender. Sign only is enabled; MailID: fffa12a9-94f6-43ff-88eb-de9071dfcaf2; Recipients: [receiver@external-domain.net] (com.ciphermail.core.app.james.mailets.Default) [spooler-740]
2.11.2026, 18:34:58 ciphermail-backend
INFO Encrypt Mode is No Encryption for the sender; MailID: fffa12a9-94f6-43ff-88eb-de9071dfcaf2; Recipients: [receiver@external-domain.net] (com.ciphermail.core.app.james.mailets.Default) [spooler-740]
2.11.2026, 18:34:58 ciphermail-backend
INFO DLP is disabled for the sender; MailID: fffa12a9-94f6-43ff-88eb-de9071dfcaf2; Recipients: [receiver@external-domain.net] (com.ciphermail.core.app.james.mailets.Default) [spooler-740]
2.11.2026, 18:34:58 ciphermail-backend
INFO To external recipient(s); MailID: fffa12a9-94f6-43ff-88eb-de9071dfcaf2; Recipients: [receiver@external-domain.net] (com.ciphermail.core.app.james.mailets.Default) [spooler-740]
2.11.2026, 18:34:58 ciphermail-backend
INFO Subject filter is disabled for the sender; MailID: fffa12a9-94f6-43ff-88eb-de9071dfcaf2; Recipients: [receiver@external-domain.net] (com.ciphermail.core.app.james.mailets.Default) [spooler-740]
2.11.2026, 18:34:58 ciphermail-backend
INFO Received ; MailID: fffa12a9-94f6-43ff-88eb-de9071dfcaf2; Recipients: [receiver@external-domain.net]; Originator: sender@internal-domain.net; Sender: sender@internal-domain.net; Remote address: 192.168.7.28; Subject: (s) Test mit Signatur Trigger; Message-ID: 22cd7ba45be94449b7506e7498abbcae@internal-domain.net; (com.ciphermail.core.app.james.mailets.Log) [spooler-740]

  1. Message “Test 2” – no trigger, “Skip Sign Only” enabled
    Result: Message was not signed.

2.11.2026, 18:35:34 ciphermail-backend
INFO Processing is finished; MailID: 366f8509-5ce4-44e9-828b-d9fcbfb1dc1e; Recipients: [receiver@external-domain.net]; Originator: sender@internal-domain.net; Sender: sender@internal-domain.net; Remote address: 192.168.7.28; Subject: Test 2; Message-ID: c819252f1e444caab9611e6916fa9880@internal-domain.net; (com.ciphermail.core.app.james.mailets.Log) [spooler-740]
2.11.2026, 18:35:34 ciphermail-backend
INFO DKIM signing is disabled for the sender; MailID: 366f8509-5ce4-44e9-828b-d9fcbfb1dc1e; Recipients: [receiver@external-domain.net] (com.ciphermail.core.app.james.mailets.Default) [spooler-740]
2.11.2026, 18:35:34 ciphermail-backend
INFO PGP sign only is disabled for the sender; MailID: 366f8509-5ce4-44e9-828b-d9fcbfb1dc1e; Recipients: [receiver@external-domain.net] (com.ciphermail.core.app.james.mailets.Default) [spooler-740]
2.11.2026, 18:35:34 ciphermail-backend
INFO S/MIME Skip Sign Only is enabled for the sender; MailID: 366f8509-5ce4-44e9-828b-d9fcbfb1dc1e; Recipients: [receiver@external-domain.net] (com.ciphermail.core.app.james.mailets.Default) [spooler-740]
2.11.2026, 18:35:34 ciphermail-backend
INFO Encrypt Mode is No Encryption for the sender; MailID: 366f8509-5ce4-44e9-828b-d9fcbfb1dc1e; Recipients: [receiver@external-domain.net] (com.ciphermail.core.app.james.mailets.Default) [spooler-740]
2.11.2026, 18:35:33 ciphermail-backend
INFO DLP is disabled for the sender; MailID: 366f8509-5ce4-44e9-828b-d9fcbfb1dc1e; Recipients: [receiver@external-domain.net] (com.ciphermail.core.app.james.mailets.Default) [spooler-740]
2.11.2026, 18:35:33 ciphermail-backend
INFO To external recipient(s); MailID: 366f8509-5ce4-44e9-828b-d9fcbfb1dc1e; Recipients: [receiver@external-domain.net] (com.ciphermail.core.app.james.mailets.Default) [spooler-740]
2.11.2026, 18:35:33 ciphermail-backend
INFO Subject filter is disabled for the sender; MailID: 366f8509-5ce4-44e9-828b-d9fcbfb1dc1e; Recipients: [receiver@external-domain.net] (com.ciphermail.core.app.james.mailets.Default) [spooler-740]
2.11.2026, 18:35:33 ciphermail-backend
INFO Received ; MailID: 366f8509-5ce4-44e9-828b-d9fcbfb1dc1e; Recipients: [receiver@external-domain.net]; Originator: sender@internal-domain.net; Sender: sender@internal-domain.net; Remote address: 192.168.7.28; Subject: Test 2; Message-ID: c819252f1e444caab9611e6916fa9880@internal-domain.net; (com.ciphermail.core.app.james.mailets.Log) [spooler-740]

  1. Message “(s) Test 2 with signature trigger” – “Skip Sign Only” enabled
    Result: Message was not signed.

2.11.2026, 18:35:56 ciphermail-backend
INFO Processing is finished; MailID: 27eb74e1-bcfe-4eab-949e-d0bffe7e24a9; Recipients: [receiver@external-domain.net]; Originator: sender@internal-domain.net; Sender: sender@internal-domain.net; Remote address: 192.168.7.27; Subject: Test 2 mit Signatur Trigger; Message-ID: 8b62d75bb7d24a72ba89add8acaa12a9@internal-domain.net; (com.ciphermail.core.app.james.mailets.Log) [spooler-740]
2.11.2026, 18:35:56 ciphermail-backend
INFO DKIM signing is disabled for the sender; MailID: 27eb74e1-bcfe-4eab-949e-d0bffe7e24a9; Recipients: [receiver@external-domain.net] (com.ciphermail.core.app.james.mailets.Default) [spooler-740]
2.11.2026, 18:35:56 ciphermail-backend
INFO PGP sign only is disabled for the sender; MailID: 27eb74e1-bcfe-4eab-949e-d0bffe7e24a9; Recipients: [receiver@external-domain.net] (com.ciphermail.core.app.james.mailets.Default) [spooler-740]
2.11.2026, 18:35:56 ciphermail-backend
INFO S/MIME is disabled for the sender; MailID: 27eb74e1-bcfe-4eab-949e-d0bffe7e24a9; Recipients: [receiver@external-domain.net] (com.ciphermail.core.app.james.mailets.Default) [spooler-740]
2.11.2026, 18:35:56 ciphermail-backend
INFO The subject contains the Sign Trigger for the sender. Sign only is enabled; MailID: 27eb74e1-bcfe-4eab-949e-d0bffe7e24a9; Recipients: [receiver@external-domain.net] (com.ciphermail.core.app.james.mailets.Default) [spooler-740]
2.11.2026, 18:35:56 ciphermail-backend
INFO Encrypt Mode is No Encryption for the sender; MailID: 27eb74e1-bcfe-4eab-949e-d0bffe7e24a9; Recipients: [receiver@external-domain.net] (com.ciphermail.core.app.james.mailets.Default) [spooler-740]
2.11.2026, 18:35:56 ciphermail-backend
INFO DLP is disabled for the sender; MailID: 27eb74e1-bcfe-4eab-949e-d0bffe7e24a9; Recipients: [receiver@external-domain.net] (com.ciphermail.core.app.james.mailets.Default) [spooler-740]
2.11.2026, 18:35:56 ciphermail-backend
INFO To external recipient(s); MailID: 27eb74e1-bcfe-4eab-949e-d0bffe7e24a9; Recipients: [receiver@external-domain.net] (com.ciphermail.core.app.james.mailets.Default) [spooler-740]
2.11.2026, 18:35:56 ciphermail-backend
INFO Subject filter is disabled for the sender; MailID: 27eb74e1-bcfe-4eab-949e-d0bffe7e24a9; Recipients: [receiver@external-domain.net] (com.ciphermail.core.app.james.mailets.Default) [spooler-740]
2.11.2026, 18:35:56 ciphermail-backend
INFO Received ; MailID: 27eb74e1-bcfe-4eab-949e-d0bffe7e24a9; Recipients: [receiver@external-domain.net]; Originator: sender@internal-domain.net; Sender: sender@internal-domain.net; Remote address: 192.168.7.27; Subject: (s) Test 2 mit Signatur Trigger; Message-ID: 8b62d75bb7d24a72ba89add8acaa12a9@internal-domain.net; (com.ciphermail.core.app.james.mailets.Log) [spooler-740]

It will be fixed in the upcoming release (planned this week)

This should be fixed in 6.5.2.

Please check

1 Like

It works. :slight_smile: Thank you very much.